Questions on reasoned amendments

28.48On reasoned amendments to the motion for second or third reading of a bill, the question proposed from the Chair is ‘that the amendment be made’. If this question is negatived, the main question is put forthwith under Standing Order No 62(2), and it is accordingly not possible for more than one reasoned amendment to be moved in respect of the second or third reading of any one bill. An opponent of a bill who does not support the terms of the particular reasoned amendment that has been moved nonetheless has an opportunity to vote against the bill on the main question; and similarly there is no procedural obstacle to a Member voting in favour of a reasoned amendment and nevertheless supporting the bill when the main question is put.1

When more than one reasoned amendment is tabled on the second or third reading of a bill, it is for the Speaker to decide, in accordance with Standing Order No 32, which, if any, to select.